Butt Plugs

Curious about anal play? Butt plugs are a great way to learn, get to know your body, and even spice up your sex life. What matters most is finding a butt plug that suits your needs, feels good, and in a size just right for your body.

Shop for All Butt Plugs

Showing 1–30 of 583 results Refine

Find the perfect butt plug

From jeweled anal plugs to ass training, butt plugs come in a wide variety of styles and can be used in many ways. The type of butt plug you need depends on what you want to feel and achieve. Ass trainer sets usually provide butt plugs in multiple sizes so you can move up as your body adjusts to the stretch and sensation of anal play. Pretty or jeweled butt plugs are often part of the fun, kinky play when you plan to show off your butt and want it to look as cute as possible.

Depending on where your love of plugs and ass play goes, you can stick with small plugs or move up to big, thick, or wide butt plugs meant to fill you up. Alone or with a partner, you can enjoy a wide variety of butt plugs, including vibrating plugs to help stimulate your body in new and exciting ways. Many people only play with butt plugs while others use them to adjust so they can try anal sex or other forms of anal play later.

FAQs About Butt Plugs

If I use butt plugs all the time, will it stretch out my butt?

For the vast majority of people, no amount of butt plug use will weaken or loosen the muscles of your sphincter. That part of your body is designed to tighten once a plug or any other item exits your body. If your anal play is too rough or painful, it’s possible to injure that part of your body, so start slow and be careful.

Doesn’t anal always hurt?

Anal sex with or without butt plugs should never hurt. The trick is to use plenty of lube and go slowly to allow your body to adjust to the sensation. If it hurts, stop or try a smaller butt plug. With enough lube and patience, anal play can and should be pain-free.

How will I know when it’s time to go up to a new size?

If your anal plug slides in with almost no effort, it’s probably time to try the next size up. Another good way to tell is if it doesn’t feel as good or tight as it once did. The same rules apply, though: use plenty of lube and go slowly to avoid pain or discomfort.

How much lube should I use for my butt plug?

Most people never use enough lube so the answer is lots of lubricant. The trick is to reapply as often as needed. If you feel any discomfort, add more. Try to use thick lubricants for any anal play but also make sure the lube you use is right for your butt plug.

What kind of lube can I use with my butt plug?

The type of lube used will be based on the material your butt plug is made from. Silicone, PVC, and jelly plugs need water based lube. Glass, plastic, or metal butt plugs can use silicone based lubricant.

Can I wear my butt plug during vaginal intercourse?

As long as it’s comfortable, absolutely. Many people report both partners feel extra sensation and tightness during vaginal penetration and butt plug use.

If you are looking for more anal items visit our anal sex toys page, or go to our homepage to find all other adult toys.

Here are some of the latest tips about butt plugs from our blog

8 Beautiful Butt Plugs You’ll Love to Use and Be Seen Using

No one ever said that a functional sex toy that feels good and gets you off can’t be beautiful, too. If you love a little bling in your sex life, especially when you bend over to tease a partner, you’ve got more options than you probably realize. Especially if you love butt plugs and want […]

Wearing a Butt Plug in Public: What You Need to Know

Looking for a kinky way to have fun with a butt plug? Want to make your sexy fun a little more public without anyone knowing? Wearing a butt plug in public may be more common than we think (you don’t know what’s going on in someone’s pants!). Before you stick a plug in and head […]

5 Things to Know About Tail Butt Plugs

Does your partner call you Foxy or Kitten? Are you intrigued by kinky elements of furry play? Love trying trying new types of butt plugs? A tail butt plug might be exactly what you need to take your sexy fun to a new level. Before you buy your first (or next) tail, here’s what you […]

How to Use a Butt Plug Safely

Does using a butt plug sound kinky to you? Are you excited at the idea of it? Ready to bend over and stick in your new plug right now? Before you stick anything anywhere, make sure you know how to keep yourself safe. Doing so will make sure the experience is a good one, instead […]

5% Off, Free Gift and Free Shipping at Jack and Jill Adult - Butt Plugs

Butt Plugs

Shop for All Butt Plugs

Corked 2 Small – Charcoal

Tails Moji’s Eggplant Plug – Black

Rocks Off Ass Berries – 7 Speed Raspberry

b-Vibe Remote Trio Plug w/3 Motors – Purple

Firefly Thriller – Pink

Pretty Love Remote Control Beaded Plug – 4 Function Black

Diogol Anni R Cat’s Eye T1 Crystal – Purple

b-Vibe Remote Triplet Anal Beads – Black

Basix Rubber Works Beginner’s Butt Plug – Red

Booty Bling – Small Purple

COLT XXL Pumper Plug – Black

Pretty Love Vibrating Penis Shaped Butt Plug – Black

Glas Amethyst Rain Glass Butt Plug

Corked 2 Small – Blue

Basix Rubber Works Beginner’s Butt Plug – Purple

Booty Bling – Small Pink

Fetish Fantasy Limited Edition Beginner’s Butt Plug – Black

Pretty Love Vibrating Bead Shaped Butt Plug – Black

Jelly Rancher Pleasure Plug Small – Pink

Booty Call Booty Rocket – Black

Diogol Anni Round Silver T1 – 25mm Fuchsia

Spectra Gels Anal Stuffer – Purple

Icicles No. 44 Hand Blown Glass Butt Plug – Clear

VeDO Quaker Anal Vibe – Midnight Madness

Pretty Love Vibrating Bulb Shaped Butt Plug – Black

Crystal Jellies 5″ Anal Delight – Purple

Crystal Jellies 6″ Anal Starter – Pink

Diogol Anni Round Silver T1 – 25mm Blue

Fifty Shades of Grey Something Forbidden Butt Plug

My 1st Anal Explorer Kit Vibrating Butt Plug and Please – Pink